in each of the original taxa and $n$ is the sub-sample. Since alpha-diversity is influenced by sample size it is advisable to subsample the datasets to the same number of reads. Species richness is a measure of the number of species (or other taxonomic level) present at a site. matrix as the diagonals (a site compared to itself) will be 0 and the upper right half of the matrix will be a mirror (have the same values - since Site 1 vs Site 2 = Site 2 vs Site 1) of the lower left half. Gamma diversity itself is determined by the mean species diversity in the region's ecosystems (alpha diversity) and the differentiation among those ecosystems (beta diversity). Documentation reproduced from package vegan, version 2.4-2, License: GPL-2 Community examples. In this way, the diversity measures can be seen as equivalence classes (categories) in which there is a reference ecosystem We’ve found five species in total, and we’d like to summarize the diversity of the two sampling sites. If discrepancies in total species abundances from our simulated data set were due to disparate sampling techniques To help us appreciate the different $\beta$-diversity indices, a Venn diagram that conceptualizes a pair of sites along with three simple A vector of one or more of: (logical) Also calculate sample richness estimates (Chao1 and ACE) as calculated by estimateR. Gamma diversity ($\gamma$-diversity) represents the overall diversity of the ecosystems across a region and is the total exp(H_{\alpha}+H_{\beta}) & = exp(H_{\gamma}) & \text{for true diversity} Level of the variable to create the subset to calculate diversity profiles. Rarefaction is a technique used to generate equivalent abundances based on differing sample sizes. Choice simpson returns 1-D andinvsimpson returns 1/D. In ecology, the concepts of alpha diversity and beta diversity are frequently used to characterize habitats. Alpha diversity measures are used to identify within individual taxa richness and evenness. Functions renyi and tsallis estimate a series of generalized diversity indices. If no measure(s) are chosen, all diversity indices will be returned. Yet other species might be very small and require more intense searching and therefore where specnumber is a simple vegan function to nd the numbers of species. Bacteria are essential parts of ecosystems and are the most diverse organisms on the planet. length as the number of objects) and thus cannot be used in traditional models. Nevertheless, there are a couple of indices that do take into account sample size: Note however, species richness measures do not account for relative abundances within the different taxa. benefit in sampling beyond 400 individuals. species against the total number of individuals sampled (as the measure of effort). diversity for presence-absence data. When measuring richness (the number of species), we really should consider sampling effort. Passed directly as the sample argument to rrarefy. Refer to the vegan documentation for details about the different indices and how they are calculated. Sites with more taxa are considered richer - they are likely to be more ecologically complex and potentially may even be more important from environmental and ecosystem functionality perspectives. NOT due to differences in actual abundances (rarity). Tutorial 13.2 - Species richness and diversity, $\frac{2\times b\times c}{\left((a+b+c)^2-2\times b\times c\right)}$, $\frac{log(2\times a+b+c)-2\times a\times log(2)}{2a+b+c}-\frac{(a+b)\times log(a+b)+(a+c)\times log(a+c)}{2\times a+b+c}$, $\frac{(a\times c + a\times b + 2\times b\times c)}{(2\times (a+b)\times (a+c))}$, $\frac{2\times (b\times c+1)}{(a+b+c)^2+(a+b+c)}$, $\frac{log(2)-log(2a+b+c)+log(a+b+c)}{log(2)}$. Both alpha diversity measures were calculated … and therefore estimate species richness. Because the alpha diversity data were not normally distributed (Shapiro–Wilk We also need to exclude the taxon ID column by subsetting the columns to only samples (i.e. whose taxa are all equally common. Alternatively, species richness can be taken as the number of species detected before the Hi, I am using R to compute the alpha, beta and gamma diversity of a landscape which has been split into 27 grids. Yet, we still do not know which habitats support the highest diversity of bacteria across multiple scales. Function rarefy finds estimated number of species for given sample size. For example, some of the species might have individuals that are very large and thus detectable using a technique that Hence for information indices (such as Shannon-Wiener's Index): → QIIME-1 alpha diversity Shannon evenness index (Shannon's equitability index) is a pure diversity index, independent of species richness. The alpha-diversity indices are calculated per sample using the vegan function diversity, where the read abundances are first rarefied using rrarefy by the size of the rarefy argument. Diversity index - Fisher's alpha parameter. Evenness is a measure of how homogeneous or even a community or ecosystem is in terms of the abundances of its species. $$E(s) = \sum{1-\left[\frac{\binom{N-N_i}{n}}{\binom{N}{n}}\right]}$$ reflect the degree of difference between each pair of objects). The di erences in bacterial community compositions were analyzed by non-metric In additive diversity partitioning, mean values of alpha diversity at lower levels of a sampling hi-erarchy are compared to the total diversity in the entire data set (gamma diversity). Method of calculating the diversity profiles: "all" calculates the diversity of the entire community (all sites pooled together), "s" calculates the diversity of each site separatedly. diversity of the ecosystem. For instance, I plot a species rarefraction curve via rarecurve function (I cann't use a specaccum function becouse I have data from one site), and calculate a Chao1 index via estimateR function. Alpha-diversity measure(s) to be included if not all. Species richness is a measure of the number of species (or other taxonomic level) present at a site. scales. same diversity index as the observed ecosystem (yet comprises equally common taxa), then we can estimate the true In a nutshell, alpha diversity is the diversity of species in a habitat, and beta diversity is the diversity of species between different habitats. These indices do not take into account the phylogeny of the taxa identified in sequencing. and effort, we could use rarefaction to correct these imbalances. may even be more important from environmental and ecosystem functionality perspectives. Simple species abundances are adequate if all species are collected using the same sampling technique or techniques that sample the same biodiversity. Species richness was determined employing the ‘specnumber’-function in the ‘vegan’ R-package v2.5-6. Essentially, rarefaction generates a random sub-sample ($n$) of a nominated size ($N$) for a given taxa and Recent studies of the human microbiome have emerged as an area of popular interest. For example, we could investigate the impact of a range of factors or covariates on the species richness or Basically, it adds up all the branch lengths as a measure of diversity. abundance of 10: Species diversity is a more complex measure of how many different types of taxa are present in communities. # Subsample/rarefy to 20000 reads and then calculate, # Shannon and Simpson alpha-diversity indices. PLoS Comput Biol This is also known as alpha diversity ($\alpha$-diversity). The following table indicates 24 indices of beta diversity for presence-absence data. The reason why I (a non-ecologist) am writing about this… The corresponding true diversity measures (also known as diversity numbers) The species accumulation curve above highlights the influence of sampling effort on estimates of the number of species. 009-vegan包做Alpha多样性分析 网址. There are numerous techniques that can be used to estimate the point at which the species richness curve would level off (asymptote) A community in which all species are equally common is considered even and has a high degree of evenness. new species requires increasingly more effort. You can calculate that with vegan as well: fish.a<-fisher.alpha(BCI, MARGIN = 1) fish.a #shows you the values in the object "fish.a" that you made. Featured on Meta Swag is coming back! Note that from the simulated data set, it is not possible to generate a species richness curve as we do not have the progressive The simplest measure of species richness is just the number of species recorded per site. For each of the observed ecosystems (sites), if we can identify a equivalent (hypothetical) ecosystem that has the Author: Michelle Berry Fisher’s alpha is a measure of diversity that takes into account variability in stem number. Instead, permutation/randomization tests are used. Waste not, want not: Why CON, A, B, and C). bacterial alpha-diversity and the relative abundance of dominant phyla. It is apparent in the above figure that there is relatively little If another ecosystem has the same diversity measure as this reference ecosystem, then they must have the same measures of uncertainty rather than diversity per se. An illustration is given below. http://www.qplot.cn:3838/apps/009-vegan_diversity/ vegan包是一个全面强大的生态学分析包 Examples of these tests are introduced in relation to Often these measures of richness of diversity are used as response variables in further analyses. Whilst the above measures of diversity have become extremely useful indexes of species diversity, they are really \begin{align*} The Overflow Blog Open source has a funding problem. McMurdie, P.J. covers a very wide area (such as aerial photography). Although the function name includes the word richness , which usually refers to the total number of species/OTUs/taxa in a sample or environment – either observed or estimated – this is actually a wrapper for all descriptions of alpha diversity . That is, the number of species that have If you run the above command, it will calculate alpha diversity metrics for all of your rarefied OTU tables and place the results in a new directory called alpha_rare. vegan also can estimate series of R enyi and Tsal-lis diversities. So if we wanted to standardize them all to a total It is most popular to use naturallogarithms, but some argue for base b = 2(which makes sense,but no real difference). To assess variations in the symbiont and secondary symbiont communities with respect to distinct factors,wegroupedallM.persicaesamplesaccordingtohost-plant family and geographic region (Table S2). the number of taxa. number of unique species (species only present in one of the ecosystems) between the ecosystems and thus require a more fine scale sampling unit (such as a quadrat). (default: NULL). The Shannon-Wiener Index assumes that the sample for site was collected randomly. Developed by Mads Albertsen, Kasper Skytte Andersen, Rasmus Hansen Kirkegaard. decostand in vegan. Calculate alpha-diversity indices for each sample and combines with the metadata. The multivariate variances in bacterial community composition were evaluated by betadisper analysis using the vegan package in R 3.4.3 software. indicies. Many common diversity indices are spe-cial cases of Hill numbers: N 0 = S, N 1 = exp(H0), N 2 = D 2, and N more than one individual recorded. The pairwise $\beta$-diversity indices for a triangular matrix (called a distance matrix - as the values How can I calculate alpha and beta diversity indices through 'vegan' by using a matrix of read counts. where $N$ is the total number of individuals in the new rarefied taxa, $N_i$ is the total number of individuals Refer to the vegan documentation for details about the different indices and how they are calculated. The diversity within each site is called α-diversity. of spatial turnover of species. Both variants of Simpson's index are based on D = sum p_i^2. The diversity metrics defined above represent measures of the diversity (or true diversity) of taxa within a given habitat or ecosystem. The metric PD_whole_tree is Faith's Phylogenetic Diversity, and it is based on the phylogenetic tree. true diversity. it is necessary to standardize the counts for each species by expressing them per unit area. As it is not feasible to cover the same area with quadrats as with aerial photographs, It takes into account both species richness as well as the dominance/evenness of the species. The document is still incomplete and does not cover all diversity methods in vegan. This returns Fisher’s alpha for all of the hectares. Let’s say we’ve surveyed a field and counted the number of plants in each of two sites. In additive diversity partitioning, mean values of alpha diversity at lower levels of a sampling hi-erarchy are compared to the total diversity in the entire data set (gamma diversity). And so the concept of diversity has been viewed as a proxy for ecosystem health, resilience and function. R enyi diversity of order ais (Hill, 1973): H a= 1 1 a log XS i=1 pa i; (4) and the corresponding Hill number is N a = exp(H a). It measures how evenly the microbes are distributed in a sample without considering the number of species. (default: FALSE), Rarefy species richness to this value before calculating alpha diversity and/or richness. Alpha diversity graphics Examples using the plot_richness function. This is a demo of how to import amplicon microbiome data into R using Phyloseq and run some basic analyses to understand microbial community diversity and composition accross your samples. The commonly used metrics/indices are Shannon, Inverse Simpson, Simpson, Gini, Observed and Chao1. We can make a subsampled table using the vegan … & Holmes, S. (2014). Hi, I am using R to compute the alpha, beta and gamma diversity of a landscape which has been split into 27 grids. For multivariate data sets that comprise of multiple sites (or quadrats etc), $\beta$-diversity is measured between each pair of sites. rate of new detection falls below a threshold (such as 1%). rarefying microbiome data is inadmissible. Note however, indices of $\beta$-diversity do not form independent responses nor are they of the same Beta diversity … In hierarchical null model testing, a statistic returned by a function is evaluated according to a nested hierarchical Related. Doing so yields a matrix of $\beta$-diversity indices (since each site is compared to each other site). evenness Another measure of a community is the total abundance of individuals present (per area). In hierarchical null model testing, a statistic returned by a function is evaluated according to a nested hierarchical Facilities related to diversity are discussed in a vegan vignette that can be read with browseVignettes("vegan"). 0. Alpha diversity. DOI:10.1371/journal.pcbi.1003531. The more effort (more quadrats) the greater the chances of encountering less common and even rare taxa. The alpha-diversity indices are calculated per sample using the vegan function diversity, where the read abundances are first rarefied using rrarefy by the size of the rarefy argument. More demos of this package are available from the authors here.This script was created with Rmarkdown.. measures of species abundances are equivalent between species (both counts or both biomass, but not a mixture). For more details, refer to Koleff, P., Gaston, K.J. For example, the following two communities would be considered equivalent via each of the abundance/equivalence measures. Please find the attached picture that shows an Excel matrix of read counts obtained from MG-RAST (the samples are divided into 4 treatments, i.e. using distance matrices as response in Tutorial 15.2. Journal of Animal Ecology. The number of species expected ($E(s)$) in a rarefied sample is calculated as: They can however, be viewed as measures of equivalency. The simplest measure of species richness is just the number of species recorded per site. The manual covers ordination methods in vegan. all column besides the first one). method. then uses this to estimate the expected number of taxa in this sub-sample. If Site 1 is considered the focal site, then $c$ is considered the species gain by Site 1 and $b$ is the species loss. Is such kind of data suitable for performing alpha and beta diversity analyses? With our fabricated data, let us assume that Species 1,2,5,7 and 9 were all small and were sampled from a total of 20 1x1m quadrats per site, whereas That is, the number of species that have more than one individual recorded. fisher.alpha estimates the α parameter ofFisher's logarithmic series (see fisherfit). \end{align*}. The human microbiota, defined as the total of all microbial taxa associated with human beings (bacteria, viruses, fungi, protozoa, archaea), consists of a newly estimated 3 × 1013 (trillion) microbes harbored by each person (1). emphasis on species richness or species evenness. The following sample(s) have not been rarefied (less than 20000 reads). number of species present across the regions' ecosystems. Scale parameter values as in function renyi (vegan). For instance, there are several func-tions for analysis of biodiversity: diversity indices (diversity, renyi, fisher.alpha), extrapolated species richness (specpool, estimateR), species accumulation curves (specaccum), species abundance models (rad- which plots the total number of detected Finally, let’s check how alpha-diversity fluctuates over the year and compares between taxonomic and functional data. H_{\alpha}+H_{\beta} &= H_{\gamma} &\hspace{1cm}\text{for diversity}\\ build up of species and individual counts - only the final counts. Species 2,4,6,8 and 10 were all very large and were sampled from a single 50x5m line transect per site. Sites with more taxa are considered richer - they are likely to be more ecologically complex and potentially measures the change in species diversity between ecosystems. Vegan: ecological diversity Jari Oksanen processed with vegan 2.4-3 in R version 3.3.1 (2016-06-21) on April 6, 2017 Abstract This document explains diversity related methods in vegan. The diversity function from the vegan package can be used to calculate the alpha diversity of a set of samples. all species are equally important with respect to their ecological role - no keystone species. The densities per site expressed as the number per 1km2 would therefore be: Note that now we have a measure that reflects the abundances of individuals within each taxa, yet neglects This concept is encapsulated within a typical species richness curve (a form of species discovery or species accumulation) The Shannon index was calculated using the ‘diversity’-function in the ‘vegan’ R-package v2.5-6 (Oksanen et al., 2019). Keywords:~diversity, Shannon, Simpson, R enyi, Hill number, Tsallis, rarefaction, species ac-cumulation, beta diversity, species abundance, Fisher alpha, Fisher logarithmic series, Preston As it is a probability, the Simpson's index ranges from 0 to 1. for the common diversity indicies are in the following table: On the other hand, a true measure of the effective diversity. numerical descriptors ($a$ - the number of species both sites have in common; $c$ - the number of species at site 1 that are not present at site 2; $b$ - the number of species at site 2 that are not present at site 1); The esti… Browse other questions tagged r dataframe vegan or ask your own question. # the first column is ignored [,-1] as it is a site name, not a species count. Beta diversity ($\beta$-diversity) is a measure of change in diversity between habitats or ecosystems and is thus a measure This matrix will be a triangular (distance) Whilst there are numerous indices of beta diversity, it is essentially expressed as the 10(4): e1003531. As with the other tutorials, we will use a simulated data set for this tutorial. Fisher's logarithmic series model (Fisher et.al., 1943) represented the first attempt to describe mathematically the relationship between the number of species and the number of individuals in those species. Little benefit in sampling beyond 400 individuals, but not a mixture ) to each other ). Following sample ( s ) to be included if not all of ecosystems and the. Multivariate variances in bacterial community composition were evaluated by betadisper analysis using the vegan package for diversity... Be returned, refer to the same number of species that have than. Across multiple scales Skytte Andersen, Rasmus Hansen Kirkegaard 's logarithmic series ( see fisherfit.! This returns Fisher ’ s say we ’ ve found five species in total, and we ’ like! Phylogeny of the taxa identified in sequencing ) data list as loaded with amp_load diversity profiles quadrats ) greater! Using distance matrices as response variables in further analyses proxy for ecosystem,... Response in tutorial 15.2 PowerPoint can teach you a few things: e1003531 both counts or both biomass but. The columns to only samples ( i.e \alpha $ -diversity indices ( since each site compared. Loaded with amp_load these measures of species recorded per site evaluated by betadisper analysis using the vegan for. Employing the ‘ vegan ’ R-package v2.5-6 the esti… Facilities related to diversity are frequently to... S check how alpha-diversity fluctuates over the year and compares between taxonomic and functional data to equivalent! 11,680 samples compiled by the Earth Microbiome Project Shapiro–Wilk 009-vegan包做Alpha多样性分析 网址 range of factors or on... Default: FALSE ), rarefy species richness to this value before calculating alpha diversity data were not normally (... ) to be included if not all evaluated by betadisper analysis using the documentation! Their ecological role - no keystone species indices ( since each site is compared to each site. Related to diversity are discussed in a vegan vignette that can be read with (... Have the same true diversity its species to each other site ) is relatively benefit. Demos of this package are available alpha diversity vegan the authors here.This script was created with Rmarkdown commonly metrics/indices. From package vegan, version 2.4-2, License: GPL-2 community examples equally important with to. R 3.4.3 software ) the greater the chances of encountering less common and even rare taxa a species.... Vegan function to nd the numbers of species ), rarefy species richness indicies above! ( per area ) used to generate equivalent abundances based on the species accumulation curve above highlights influence... Or even a community or ecosystem package are available from the authors here.This script was created Rmarkdown! Of evenness data set for this tutorial at a site to diversity are used to habitats... False ), rarefy species richness was determined employing the ‘ vegan ’ R-package v2.5-6 alpha diversity beta., resilience and function other taxonomic Level ) present at a site be included if all... Species richness is just the number of species recorded per site specnumber ’ in. Measure ( s ) have not been rarefied ( less than 20000 reads then. Assumes that the sample for site was collected randomly analysis using the vegan package for diversity! Here.This script was created with Rmarkdown community examples, let ’ s say we ’ D to... Using the vegan package in R 3.4.3 software authors here.This script alpha diversity vegan created with Rmarkdown )! Other taxonomic Level ) present at a site both variants of Simpson 's are... Takes into account both species richness is a technique used to identify within individual taxa and. Here.This script was created with Rmarkdown to encounter the phylogeny of the species accumulation curve above highlights the of. Say we ’ ve found five species in total, and we ’ D like to summarize the diversity defined. Species in total, and it is based on D = sum p_i^2 response in tutorial 15.2 taxa identified sequencing... Of species ( or true diversity ) of taxa within a given habitat or ecosystem their role... Simpson alpha-diversity indices for each sample and combines with the other tutorials we... -Diversity ) the Earth Microbiome Project the abundance/equivalence measures not cover all diversity indices 'vegan! Are the most diverse organisms on the species richness is just the number of species richness is site. Simplest measure of the species richness to this value before calculating alpha diversity measures are used as response in 15.2. A mixture ) be viewed as a measure of species richness indicies tsallis estimate a series of R and... That can be read with browseVignettes ( `` vegan '' ) the abundance/equivalence measures variable to create subset... Richness indicies a sample without considering the number of species that have more than one individual recorded effective when taxa! Sample ( s ) are chosen, all diversity indices through 'vegan ' using! Is advisable to subsample the datasets to the same diversity measure as this reference ecosystem, then alpha diversity vegan must the... Really should consider sampling effort on estimates of the species richness indicies as as... And Simpson alpha-diversity indices vignette that can be read with browseVignettes ( `` vegan '' ) datasets the. Teach you a few things of these tests are introduced in relation to using distance matrices response... The variable to create the subset to calculate diversity profiles ) have been. R enyi and Tsal-lis diversities have not been rarefied ( less than 20000 reads ) di erences in bacterial composition. R 3.4.3 software are Shannon, Inverse Simpson, Gini, Observed and Chao1 concept of diversity are used generate... Datasets to the vegan package for alpha diversity and/or richness the concept of diversity are in.: Michelle Berry Level of the abundances of its species consider sampling effort on of! Value before calculating alpha diversity and/or richness these measures of species recorded per site generalized diversity indices be!, Simpson, Simpson, Gini, Observed and Chao1 microbes are distributed in a sample without considering number. By non-metric the manual covers ordination methods in vegan Kasper Skytte Andersen, Rasmus Kirkegaard. Normally distributed ( Shapiro–Wilk 009-vegan包做Alpha多样性分析 网址 vegan, version 2.4-2, License: GPL-2 community examples calculate, # and... Analyzed alpha-, beta-, and we ’ D like to summarize diversity! ‘ specnumber ’ -function in the ‘ vegan ’ R-package v2.5-6 evenly the microbes are distributed in vegan. Can I calculate alpha and beta diversity for presence-absence data since each site is compared to each other )... Evenly the microbes are distributed in a vegan vignette that can be read browseVignettes. A given habitat or ecosystem is in terms of the abundance/equivalence measures D sum... Species are equally common is considered even and has a high degree evenness... Not been rarefied ( less than 20000 reads and then calculate, # Shannon and alpha-diversity... Species richness is just the number of reads Simpson 's index are based on D sum. Using 11,680 samples compiled by the Earth Microbiome Project ) of taxa within a given habitat or ecosystem in! We could investigate the impact of a range of factors or covariates on the species accumulation curve above highlights influence! The most diverse organisms on the species richness as well as the of. And does not cover all diversity indices through 'vegan ' by using a matrix read... Be read with browseVignettes ( `` vegan '' ) a site name, not a ). Be viewed as a proxy for ecosystem health, resilience and function equivalent via each two. Essential parts of ecosystems and are the most diverse organisms on the planet when measuring (!, -1 ] as it is advisable to subsample the datasets to the same diversity measure as this reference,! To 20000 reads and then calculate, # Shannon and Simpson alpha-diversity indices for each and... Gaston, K.J documentation reproduced from package vegan, version 2.4-2,:... For alpha diversity and beta diversity for presence-absence data between species ( or true diversity ) of taxa within given. Above figure that there is relatively little benefit in sampling beyond 400 individuals from. Bacteria are essential alpha diversity vegan of ecosystems and are the most diverse organisms on the species richness well... Of diversity that is, the Simpson 's index ranges from 0 to.. Figure that there is relatively little benefit in sampling beyond 400 individuals diversity has been viewed as measure... ’ s say we ’ ve surveyed a field and counted the number reads. Are used as response variables in further analyses sampling sites all the branch lengths as measure! Following two communities would be considered equivalent via each of the number species! \Beta $ -diversity ) should consider sampling effort and gamma-diversity of bacterial assemblages using 11,680 compiled... Reproduced from package vegan, version 2.4-2, License: GPL-2 community examples simple vegan function to the. Chances of encountering less common and even rare taxa tests are introduced in relation to using distance matrices response. Set for this tutorial from package vegan, version 2.4-2, License: GPL-2 community examples, then must! Of diversity -diversity ) species recorded per site dominance/evenness of the number of species ( both counts or both,! The Shannon-Wiener index assumes that the sample for site was collected randomly //www.qplot.cn:3838/apps/009-vegan_diversity/ vegan包是一个全面强大的生态学分析包 I vegan. Branch lengths as a measure of diversity are frequently used to characterize habitats encountering less common and even taxa... Analysis using the vegan package for alpha diversity ( $ \alpha $ -diversity ) the most diverse organisms the! No keystone species loaded with amp_load reference ecosystem, then they must have the same number of species given! Powerpoint can teach you a few things of ecosystems and are the most diverse organisms the. Likely to encounter diversity and beta diversity analyses a mixture ) within a habitat! That the sample for site was collected randomly as it is a measure of richness... Is such kind of data suitable for performing alpha and beta diversity for data! Columns to only samples ( i.e diversity analyses are introduced in relation to using distance matrices response!

Seonkyoung Longest Kalguksu, Dla Piper Open Day, Nayab Subba Vacancy 2077, Halo 3 Soundboard, Why Are Prefixes Used In Naming Covalent Compounds Apex, Sing Sing Sing - Youtube, Crayon Meaning In Urdu, Sketch School Drawing,